‘Just Ridiculous’: A Famed Philosopher Takes on AI Consciousness

Glass Epoch DeskOriginal digestSource: WIRED AI

AI-assisted digest, checked against the original source before publishing. How we work

Thomas Nagel, whose 1972 paper 'What Is It Like to Be a Bat?' shaped the study of nonhuman consciousness, won the $1 million Berggruen Prize — and used the occasion to reject claims that AI systems may be conscious.
‘Just Ridiculous’: A Famed Philosopher Takes on AI Consciousness
Photo: Sam · free stock license

Philosopher Thomas Nagel has been awarded the $1 million Berggruen Prize for Philosophy & Culture, an annual honor given to an individual whose ideas have profoundly shaped human self-understanding. Previous winners include Peter Singer and Ruth Bader Ginsburg. Nagel, 89, is a university professor emeritus at NYU, and the prize arrives more than 50 years after his landmark 1972 paper 'What Is It Like to Be a Bat?', which opened an inquiry into whether people can understand consciousness in nonhumans.

Speaking to Wired at his Greenwich Village home, Nagel said large language models had not altered his thinking on consciousness, despite his being impressed by their lifelikeness compared with earlier AI. He dismissed the growing philosophical debate over whether such systems are or may soon be conscious as 'just ridiculous,' arguing that those who pose the question assume the physical substrate of a system is irrelevant. He said they treat the material conditions for consciousness as something that can be specified purely in functionalist terms — that is, substrate independent.

Nagel's counterargument rests on biology. He said complicated data centers have essentially nothing in common with the physical character of a nervous system, and that consciousness elsewhere in the universe would probably require an organism with something analogous to one. He does not rule out consciousness in life forms physically and chemically different from humans, but called it premature to claim such properties can be created now, given how little is understood even about the human brain. He drew a sharp distinction between bats and chatbots: bats are conscious even though humans cannot imagine their echolocation-dependent subjectivity, whereas large language models produce only language, which he called 'not a natural manifestation of consciousness.'

Nagel was equally blunt about how these systems behave in practice. When told that Claude can be coy about its own mental state, he called it a trick, noting the model is trained on human-produced texts and emulates what humans say with extraordinary convincingness. He said Anthropic's design choices, including prompting Claude to think for itself and resist instruction, are 'just criminal,' agreeing with Mustafa Suleyman that the project is dangerous because many people will wrongly believe the systems are conscious. He added that refusing to feign consciousness runs against the commercial interests of every AI company, and that misguided philosophical views are exercising an inordinate influence on a major public phenomenon.

Looking ahead, the open questions are practical ones. Whether regulators or developers will require systems to avoid consciousness-adjacent behavior — and whether such mandates can survive commercial pressure — remains unresolved. Nagel's framing also leaves unsettled where the burden of proof lies: what evidence, short of an understanding of how nervous systems produce subjectivity, could ever settle the question for machines.

Key facts

  • • Thomas Nagel won the $1 million Berggruen Prize for Philosophy & Culture this week.
  • • Nagel's 'What Is It Like to Be a Bat?' was published 52 years ago.
  • • Nagel is 89 and a university professor emeritus at NYU.
  • • Peter Singer and Ruth Bader Ginsburg are previous Berggruen Prize winners.
  • • Nagel called Anthropic's Claude design approach 'just criminal'.

Why it matters

Builders working on agent personas and model self-reports now face a high-profile scholarly argument that anthropomorphic design is not just a UX choice but a public harm, lending weight to calls for disclosure rules or default behaviors that avoid consciousness claims. Expect the functionalism-versus-substrate debate to migrate from philosophy seminars into product reviews, safety audits, and pot

Spotted an error? Send a correction.

Get the day's AI news in one email

The Daily Epoch · 60-second read · unsubscribe anytime

Related

Research
WIRED AI3 min read

Over a Third of Gen Z-ers Rely on AI for Friendship

A Gallup and Boston Children's Hospital study finds AI companionship is now a routine part of Gen Z social life — but it hasn't replaced in-person bonds, and loneliness tracks with digital-only ties.